Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Humpy]

I decided to pick up an Islander Steelheader Centerpin Reel but I am having a hard time choosing a rod.
It will be used for all species of Salmon and Steelhead, in the Vedder, Chehalis, Stave, etc.
I want to spend under $200. I've narrowed my list down to...
Shimano Clarus 13'0" 8-12lb 1/8-3/4oz Moderate Light
Shimano Convergence 10'6" 
Fenwick HMX Salmon/Steelhead 10'6"
Trophy XL 10" 8-15lb

[ChumChaser]

I think 13 feet is overkill, I find transport and storage of anything over 11 feet a pain but that's just me. Of the other three rods I would say they are all about the same quality. I would go with the trophy, they have a great warranty and are local so turnaround is quick.

[Humpy]

I think 13 feet is overkill, I find transport and storage of anything over 11 feet a pain but that's just me. Of the other three rods I would say they are all about the same quality. I would go with the trophy, they have a great warranty and are local so turnaround is quick.

Thanks, would 10" be fine, I thought maybe it was too short? Which Action and Power should I be looking for in the  trophy xl?

[bcguy]

One thing I found with the entry level pin rods is that many, including my original Convergence purchase, have screw down reel holders.
Which I have found to be most irritating after an hour or two of fishing. Your finger feels like it gets rubbed raw by the exposed threads. Try to find a rod with a reel seat that has the threaded ring that screws from the bottom up. It makes a big difference. Convergence although a good entry level rod could have been so much better if this one small feature was changed. Oh...and 10 1/2 feet is plenty of length.

[Humpy]

One thing I found with the entry level pin rods is that many, including my original Convergence purchase, have screw down reel holders.
Which I have found to be most irritating after an hour or two of fishing. Your finger feels like it gets rubbed raw by the exposed threads. Try to find a rod with a reel seat that has the threaded ring that screws from the bottom up. It makes a big difference. Convergence although a good entry level rod could have been so much better if this one small feature was changed. Oh...and 10 1/2 feet is plenty of length.

Thanks, I'll take a look at all of them in person before I make the decision.

[leapin' tyee]

I decided to pick up an Islander Steelheader Centerpin Reel but I am having a hard time choosing a rod.
It will be used for all species of Salmon and Steelhead, in the Vedder, Chehalis, Stave, etc.
I want to spend under $200. I've narrowed my list down to...
Shimano Clarus 13'0" 8-12lb 1/8-3/4oz Moderate Light
Shimano Convergence 10'6" 
Fenwick HMX Salmon/Steelhead 10'6"
Trophy XL 10" 8-15lb

If you going to use it for all species of salmon like(big springs , chums etc).
Shimano Clarus 13'0" 8-12lb 1/8-3/4oz Moderate Light and
Trophy XL 10" 8-15lb is a bit on the light side.

[Humpy]

If you going to use it for all species of salmon like(big springs , chums etc).
Shimano Clarus 13'0" 8-12lb 1/8-3/4oz Moderate Light and
Trophy XL 10" 8-15lb is a bit on the light side.

I will be using it for springs and chum, is a 10-20lb line rating ideal? What power and action? 

[BCfisherman97]

I have 3 of those HMX's in the 10-20 and love them. Although I do like the older version over the newer ones.

Also have used that Trophy rod for coho in smaller rivers and is perfect for coho and steelhead. Wouldn't use it for targeting chums or springs but they are fine once in a while as a by-catch.

[leapin' tyee]

I will be using it for springs and chum, is a 10-20lb line rating ideal? What power and action?

Good choice,  medium to medium heavy.  Slow action or Fast action will be up to your liking.   

[Humpy]

Thanks guys, I will pick up a Fenwick HMX.

[leapin' tyee]

Thanks guys, I will pick up a Fenwick HMX.

Shimano is a soft action rod and Fenwick is fast action. Try both if you can before you make up your decision.  Good luck .

[TheChumWhisperer]

I have the Amundsen 8-17, 10"6".  Found it to be an excellent entry level CP rod, and a much better rod than the Fenwick.  I have an extra one if you're interested in it.

[bald_seagull]

streamside heritage salmon rod is a beauty i dunno about the warranty as i havent broken one yet only had it for a year

[canso]

Love my HMX for the pin, also use them with moochers on the rigger.

[Carich980]

That Lamiglass BC series CP rod sure is nice, I think its near 250ish. It s an all around species rod. Maybe you could find a used one if the new price is to high.