--In the all-new none hitting NHL why would size matter. Crosby, Marchand, Gallagher all did well even when hitting was allowed.
--Just look at the names of all the former and current BC grown NHLer's, I'm sure there is an all-star team full of players. Always look to homegrown over store bought.
Yep good point. Some smaller players are average so better to have a more physical bigger player but when it comes to Ty Ronning ....he comes from the same mold as his dad. Chip off the old block. The guy skates hard & fast. & has the talent to score. A team needs all their lines to score goals & better to have 5-6 guys who are extra skilled to have a nose to score. More the better.
Stan the steamer was not big & he was durable as was Cliff Ronning. Sometimes the smaller players have an act to avoid big hits. Why because they are aware what's happening around them.
Montreal Canadians years ago had an iron man who played so many games without getting hurt ( or even the flu I guess? ) He was not a big guy. Bible thumper I think. ( maybe the angels protected him

) Vegas in part lost to the Caps because they went thru big physical hard hitting teams & they were totally bumped up & bruised. Not much left in the tank when they faced the Caps who were the fresher healthier team. Kings Sharks & Jets really pounded Vegas.
So ya I see Dogbreath's point that having bigger players are a plus.
But say a balance of 80% bigger guys & 20% smaller but extra good goal scorers. Hopefully the bigger guys can get 20-25 or more goals.