Both proponents of seasonal closures and permanent closures have very good points. To understand what the controversy is, one should understand different perspectives in this issue. The purpose of this boundary shift/section closure is to ensure that the hatchery obtains the number of red chinook salmon broodstocks that it requires. This management measure was decided after the hatchery had trouble achieving this last year. The questioned section, Limit Hole, is where these fish and many other spawning salmonid tend to stage together instead of moving into the hatchery channel right away.
With fish staging together in large numbers, it brings out two types of individuals that behave in ways that are not acceptable in BC's recreational fishery. One is seasoned users who are fully aware of their action and do not have a problem with catching these staging fish in any way possible. The other is newcomers in this sport who have a tendency to watch what others are doing and copying as it is often the only way to learn. The Chilliwack River, being an easily accessed fishery that is so close to Vancouver, has no shortage of these entry-level users.
That being said, the Upper Fraser Valley SFAC wanted to make sure the DFO is implementing this change to ensure the hatchery obtains the broodstocked needed, not to close off angling access due to poor angling behaviour. It is not suggesting that this types of behaviour should not be condemned, but one has to question where do we draw the line if we are to close access based on behaviour. Perhaps 100 meters upstream and downstream of Keith Wilson Bridge, Vedder Crossing, Peach Road, Vedder Road, railway bridge, Tamahi Rapids should also be closed as the same types of behaviour are just as widespread in these areas. Where will users who conduct themselves this way go when areas are closed? Closure based on behaviour may seem like a instant problem solver, but in the long run it may cause more damages than goods. Closures only shut out those who obey regulations, not those who are not concerned about how their actions can affect others and the resource.
Two better strategies are needed to solve the problems that seem to be growing - Education and enforcement. There has to be more public outreaching and a better educational channel where entry-level anglers can obtain information to raise our angling standard. Yes, there is a learning curve and most entry-level anglers will make mistakes, but lets make sure they have a way to learn those mistakes so they do not assume that they are doing something correctly. Enforcement is needed to pressure those who choose not to play by the rules. Both strategies would work more effectively with anglers' participation. Join a sportfishing affiliation such as the Fraser Valley Salmon Society in your area so you can be part of a strong voice that makes changes. Be involved in angling educational programs such as Fish For the Future that many of us had just put on two weeks ago. Phone in to report violations whenever you witness one.
Author
Topic: Chilliwack River upper boundary shift begins on July 27th (Read 13104 times)