Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum

Fishing in British Columbia => General Discussion => Topic started by: TayC on October 25, 2011, 08:38:30 PM

Title: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: TayC on October 25, 2011, 08:38:30 PM
During my bushwacking travels this weekend on Vedder/Chilliwack I came across some very unusual sightings that I have never seen before. I had come across many large dead white springs that seemed to be dragged atleast 5-10 feet off shore and even a couple up on a 7ft bank, they were in groups of 3s, 2s or all alone.  The wierd thing however was that on every one of them the top halves of their heads were cut off and taken away.  Basically it was a clean cut (im guessing by a large/sharp blade) going straight down through the head to where the corner of the mouth is and the bottom jaw left on. There were a mix of males and females, none had been gutted not even the does. The springs had no claw marks on them so I am ruling out any bear/cat activity.

Am I going crazy or has anyone else come across this?
Does anyone know the reasoning behind this?

Every one i have explained this too are just as stumped as I am.

I would have snapped some pics but didnt have a camera on hand.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: NiceFish on October 25, 2011, 08:44:04 PM
I have seen this before, its fish counters so they are marked off and won't be counted twice, a measure to keep estimates accurate
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: TayC on October 25, 2011, 08:46:22 PM
I have seen this before, its fish counters so they are marked off and won't be counted twice, a measure to keep estimates accurate

Thanks for the info!
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: canso on October 25, 2011, 08:49:53 PM
they count the dead fish on the side of the river
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: silver ghost on October 25, 2011, 09:12:40 PM
The group that I count fish with use a machete and chop em in half.  Could they be looking for those pin chips that are inserted in the heads of fish?That would explain why the top of the head is missing but I think they only put them in clipped fish?

Exactly what I thought. I don't know exactly what goes on at the hatchery regarding the clipping of chinook, but I have noticed a trend in other rivers that hatcheries release chinook fry that are too young o be clipped...but not too young to be wire tagged? Maybe, just speculating as I too had thought only clipped fish get tagged.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: jon5hill on October 25, 2011, 09:21:59 PM
they are taking heads to scan for coded wire tags.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: Dave on October 25, 2011, 09:39:16 PM
During my bushwacking travels this weekend on Vedder/Chilliwack I came across some very unusual sightings that I have never seen before. I had come across many large dead white springs that seemed to be dragged atleast 5-10 feet off shore and even a couple up on a 7ft bank, they were in groups of 3s, 2s or all alone.  The wierd thing however was that on every one of them the top halves of their heads were cut off and taken away.  Basically it was a clean cut (im guessing by a large/sharp blade) going straight down through the head to where the corner of the mouth is and the bottom jaw left on. There were a mix of males and females, none had been gutted not even the does. The springs had no claw marks on them so I am ruling out any bear/cat activity.

Am I going crazy or has anyone else come across this?
Does anyone know the reasoning behind this?

Every one i have explained this too are just as stumped as I am.

I would have snapped some pics but didnt have a camera on hand.
You have observed  DFO’s Chilliwack River chinook stock assessment crew in action.  They count, cut carcasses (sometimes; these are big fish) and often remove otoliths , an inner ear bone from the skull area to determine the fish’s age in designated areas of the system.
Jon, I may be wrong (Buck?) but I don’t think Chilliwack chinooks are CWTagged.


Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: TheChumWhisperer on October 25, 2011, 09:51:42 PM
Fish head soup??
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: 66TWH on October 26, 2011, 12:43:34 PM
correct me if im wrong but this sparked my memory of an episode of "Dirty Jobs" with Mike Rowe and they were on the Vedder doing exactly this. Maybe it could be found online.     
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: Nitroholic on October 26, 2011, 12:50:47 PM
correct me if im wrong but this sparked my memory of an episode of "Dirty Jobs" with Mike Rowe and they were on the Vedder doing exactly this. Maybe it could be found online.     

That was on some river in California iirc
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: buck on October 26, 2011, 03:01:29 PM
 Dave, approximately 400 k chinook are marked annually from the hatchery. 200k ad/clipped cwt and 200k cwt only. Double index marking was under taken to determine  survival rates between the two groups. There is some evidence that the ad clipped group survive at a lower rate.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: Dave on October 26, 2011, 03:15:35 PM
Thanks buck - knew you'd know :D
Apologies Jon
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: Geff_t on October 26, 2011, 04:04:21 PM
I have seen the top half of heads missing on fish but they were eaten by coyotes and bears.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: TayC on October 26, 2011, 04:20:30 PM
I have seen the top half of heads missing on fish but they were eaten by coyotes and bears.

I have heard of this as well but these were clean cuts, as stated probably with a machete
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: BigFisher on October 26, 2011, 04:24:10 PM
Fish count, I see it all along the harrison during the fall. Its one hell of a job!  ;)
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: steelie-slayer on October 26, 2011, 04:57:57 PM
i see many springs like this in the upper chilliwack river, talked to a guy doing the dead and said it was to see how many fish have spawned and how many more are still entering. also they check them to see wheter there red springs or whites to try and keep track of red spring numbers.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: SeaRun on October 26, 2011, 06:40:51 PM
You guys are all wrong.... it is fish mutilations by aliens. ;D
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: bederko on October 26, 2011, 08:41:14 PM
Aaahhh, dead-pitching springs, I truly miss those days.  Seining at the bailey bridge and disc tagging, rafting the upper river with my dog and packing 25 huge white spring heads in ziplocs on my back while hiking 10 km to the waiting truck!  I remember one very wet day when after pitching one of the spawning channels in the upper, my partner Mark took his hat off and threw it on the dash of the rented pickup with the heat blasting to warm up.  What a stench when the big hunk of rotten chum that was stuck on the brim heated up and got cookin'... Some great times with Buck, Donaldson and KP out there.
Title: Re: Odd sightings this weekend (involving the heads of dead springs)
Post by: Tee on October 26, 2011, 09:48:45 PM
Dave, approximately 400 k chinook are marked annually from the hatchery. 200k ad/clipped cwt and 200k cwt only. Double index marking was under taken to determine  survival rates between the two groups. There is some evidence that the ad clipped group survive at a lower rate.

I caught and retained one clipped chinook jack in September. Creel survey staff request the head of the fish so the implanted cwt could be retrieved as I was told.