OK , Thanks fellas . Just thinking , if its a half hour or so run to the fishing grounds that would cut into the 4hr trip . Better off booking say , 6hr charter so's you could increase your chances maybe . 3hrs would go fast, me thinks .
4 hour charters are good for people with a passing interest in fishing (or someone who drags their significant other along who isn't into fishing at all). I'd book for as long as you can afford, ideally 6 or 8 hours!
I've done both short and long charters over the years and watching the clock on a 4 hour charter (~3 hours of fishing) really detracted from my enjoyment. Didn't help that we struck out completely on that charter (going for halibut out of Victoria).
I did a charter out of Tofino many years ago and the chinook bite was on that day, way the heck out somewhere in open water. Took 45 minutes to get there, then took me about five minutes before I was puking so hard I couldn't breathe. Huge rolling waves, gray fog, no land in sight. We hooked a 22lb fish almost immediately (I had to pass the rod because I couldn't stand up), landed it, then left for calmer water to troll for coho. The guide was so sad to leave the spot