Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum
Fishing in British Columbia => General Discussion => Topic started by: chris gadsden on October 31, 2011, 05:07:13 AM
-
What your take on this?
CG
RAFE HERE … as a supporter of the OCCUPY movement I’m constantly told that this is just the usual bunch of whiners and pot heads.
I give no answer myself but let Nanaimo do so.
JOURNAL ENTRY FROM OCCUPY NANAIMO ~ Saturday, October 29th, 2011
We are Occupy Nanaimo.
Here in Diana Krall Plaza Nanaimo, we stand in solidarity with 2,217 cities across the globe asking for change.
A lot of people do not understand why we are here. Why we occupy. Why we protest. We are here to try and make the voice of the people heard. If you are in debt, you have reason to be here. If raising a family is becoming too difficult with the low number of jobs available and low wages, you have reason to be here. If you have ever called the streets your home because in the end of the day there was just nowhere else to go, you have reason to be here. If you have a grievance with the current world-wide system, you have reason to be here.
We are not just a group of protestors angry at the world. We are not a bunch of jobless hippies. We are many...both working and jobless, people with homes and people without.
Things are not OK. Just look at the injustices of this world. Too long have the people of this world been filled with greed. We watch now as Canada steps ahead of other countries, but not in a positive way. The wealth distribution gap between the rich and the poor grows more and more every year, and in Canada it grows faster than nearly any other nation on the planet.
We are here to be a part of the change in the world.
This is what our democratic system should be like.
So we ask you Citizens of Nanaimo, Citizens of Vancouver Island, Citizens in what should be a truly free country for your support. Come down to us, lend your voice to change. Set up a tent or just stand and talk. Hold a sign or simply be with us in spirit. We are here to provide an outlet for YOUR change, all of our change. If you have grievances with the world, come and talk to us. If you have grievances with us, come and talk to us. If you just want to know what this is all about, come talk to us. We will change the world, but we need everyone’s support first.
OCCUPY NANAIMO
Link: http://www.occupynanaimo.ca/
-
I see this issue as very similar to the Alex Morton/fish farm issue.....
Corporations and in particular financial institutions have been ignoring logic and common sense, taking huge risks and ultimately the public is paying for it with a depressed economy and sub par investment performance. The corporations will continue to do it because they can. Only when the public is made aware of the situation and makes a lot of noise, will government get involved and makes changes to laws and enforcement, in order to control the corporations.
Profits are good, compensation incentives are also good, however when they are at the sole expense of the public, they are obviously damaging.
Occupy may have some legs! While many of their ideas are unrealistic and impractical, they could have an influence on the politicians. As a result to pendulum may eventually swing towards a financial system that not only generates profits but also looks out for societies interests as well.
Can you see the similarity to what Morton is doing?
-
I fail to see what the protest is going to accomplish. It consist of various ad hoc groups wanting their voices heard. The protestors have no agenda or goals. Precisely what does the protestors want their government to do ? Raise higher corporate taxes ? Legislate their business practices ?
-
I just want to know when this will be over. tired of looking at a tent city in front of the vancouver art gallery. when will they realize that government isnt going to tax corporations more and give the money to them? "tax and spend" doesnt work look at the US in the 60s/70s. the problem with any welfare system is that it creates an increasing demand for itself.
-
I just want to know when this will be over. tired of looking at a tent city in front of the vancouver art gallery. when will they realize that government isnt going to tax corporations more and give the money to them? "tax and spend" doesnt work look at the US in the 60s/70s. the problem with any welfare system is that it creates an increasing demand for itself.
I don't really expect a lot from them because as has been said they are generally disorganized, and lack a clear agenda. However this could take on a life of it's own. It's not the corporations that are the problem, it's the individuals running them. These individuals have managed the corporations to the brink of bankruptcy which required taxpayers dollars to save them! Many many folks have had their financial lives affected dramatically as a result of the greed of many corporate executives. I don't believe the occupy agenda is to "tax corporations and give the money to them".
History however has had it's moments where a small group of disorganized individuals have influenced government enough to make them implement changes.... There are many examples, slavery and women's rights being just two ......
-
doesnt work look at the US in the 60s/70s.
Some of the most precious freedoms and rights that we take for granted today were hatched in social movements in the US and other western countries in the 60s and 70s.
Try and it might work.
Don't try and it certainly won't.
Just like fishing. ;)
-
Try and it might work.
Don't try and it certainly won't.
Just like fishing.
isnt that the truth! I have yet to catch a fish without wetting a line.
-
Why we protest.
We are here to try and make the voice of the people heard.
Thats great, an unquantifiable "goal". Like the special interest groups that lobby for money to "raise awareness".
If you are in debt, you have reason to be here.
so that would mean 95% of all Canadians who SIGNED A CONTRACT TO TAKE OUT SAID DEBT, the onus is on YOU to pay it back or not take it out in the first place
If raising a family is becoming too difficult
when was raising a family EVER promised to be anything BUT difficult?
with the low number of jobs available
That is straight up crap. There are TONS of job openings RIGHT NOW, statscan as of October 2011;
Following two months of little change, employment rose by 61,000 in September, all in full time. This increase pushed the unemployment rate down 0.2 percentage points to 7.1%, the lowest rate since December 2008.
In the 12 months to September, employment has grown by 1.7% (+294,000), primarily in Ontario and Alberta. Over this period, full-time employment rose by 2.5% (+344,000), part-time work declined 1.5% (-50,000) and total actual hours worked increased 2.0%.
and low wages,
its not how much you make but how much you spend. Live in a smaller place, move out of the city, get a room mate(s), eat properly, grow some veggies and make due, we all do
North America provides you the opportunity to have what you need. And possibly everything you ever wanted. At the end of the day it is up to YOU to get it. Not passively expect it.
I went to an inner city highschool in East Van, I didn't graduate (even after staying an extra year) I went to continuing education to finish my high school diploma, worked 40 hours per week while putting myself through Douglas College and racking up student loans. I moved to Prince George to go to University, I volunteered in student government, racked up more student loans, lived in a crappy house with 5 other people (but rent/hydro was $275/month). I ate the most basic stuff and got through school with a Marketing Management Diploma and then a BComm in Finance. Whoopty doo, so did many of the thousands of my fellow students. Doesn't make me special, but at the end of the day, I put in the time, the work, the effort and made the sacrifices to now be able to provide myself and my family with a very comfortable life.
The only people thatI agree with that need and deserve our help are those with mental health/addiction issues and physical disabilities which prevent them from dedicating their time and effort to support themselves and be productive members of society.
To everyone else, I don't really have the patience.
-
I don't really expect a lot from them because as has been said they are generally disorganized, and lack a clear agenda. However this could take on a life of it's own. It's not the corporations that are the problem, it's the individuals running them. These individuals have managed the corporations to the brink of bankruptcy which required taxpayers dollars to save them! Many many folks have had their financial lives affected dramatically as a result of the greed of many corporate executives. I don't believe the occupy agenda is to "tax corporations and give the money to them".
History however has had it's moments where a small group of disorganized individuals have influenced government enough to make them implement changes.... There are many examples, slavery and women's rights being just two ......
Couldn't agree more......peaceful protest is a fundamental pillar of democracy and social change.
-
I'm with Damian on this one. All I ever here is complaints that the bank won't give me a loan. Then complaints that they loaned out too much and now some people can't pay it back. Stupid banks should be more understanding. Tax the corporations, but my pension and RRSP should grow faster so I can retire. People forget that these corporations are the same entities that we rely on for retirement, jobs and the goods and services that we have gotten so accustomed to. I want more for less is the mantra of today. Stainless steel applicances, a nice home, ready made meals, a good job and longer vacations. Look at the ridiculous house sizes and prices. All driven by people sending everyone off to work so that they can keep up with the Jones'. And when we get in over our head, we complain that the government should have protected us.
We all need to take more responsibilty. Work harder, give away more and be content to live off less. Stop blaming the faceless government and companies and step up. Start something that creates a better place for all of us, not just you. "Occupy" just exudes another form of selfishness in my opinion. "Everybody help me, because I am finding it too hard to get what I want." :'(
-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accounting_scandals
These type of things can affect your pension too. Alwaysfishn made a good post about:
"It's not the corporations that are the problem, it's the individuals running them. These individuals have managed the corporations to the brink of bankruptcy which required taxpayers dollars to save them! Many many folks have had their financial lives affected dramatically as a result of the greed of many corporate executives. I don't believe the occupy agenda is to "tax corporations and give the money to them".
I read an article some years back about psychopaths and what they do for a living. We all can pay the price for not recognizing a psycho let loose with lot's of power. These people are your family and friends. Until they screw you over. :-\
-
what scares me is when big business gets into politics and there hidden agendas
-
You know what scares me? Carnies. Circus folk. Nomads, you know. Smell like cabbage. Small hands.
-
I see this issue as very similar to the Alex Morton/fish farm issue.....
Corporations and in particular financial institutions have been ignoring logic and common sense
From what my fisheries research buddies tell me Alex Morton has been ignoring a lot of logic and common sense too. Apparently the vast majority of scientific research into fish farms does not find any CONCLUSIVE evidence of harm to wild stocks. But hey, why let the truth get in the way of a good story??
-
My wife's writing her masters paper on Alex Morton and no logic being ignored Read deeper and do all your research you'll see
-
From what my fisheries research buddies tell me Alex Morton has been ignoring a lot of logic and common sense too. Apparently the vast majority of scientific research into fish farms does not find any CONCLUSIVE evidence of harm to wild stocks. But hey, why let the truth get in the way of a good story??
Ignore what's happened in Chile Norway Britain etc all you want. One day the only salmon you'll be fishing for will be at Marine Harvests pay and play.
-
So yeah, the thread's about the Occupy thingy. Not the fish farm thingy.
-
Its called working!
-
I remember working for $9.50 an hour and found it VERY difficult to make ends meet, paying rent, eating more than Mac n Cheese, buying gas etc. That was in the 90s. I cannot imagine what life is like for people working for minimum wage today, or worse as those poor saps at IHop who have to work for less (since they serve alcohol in IHop these servers will still only make only $8.75). This minimum wage is set by the politicians that only a few years ago voted themselves huge wage increases of between 20 - 40%. It is not hard to see why the protestors are occupying. The disparities are out of whack. It is not a matter of being lazy and wanting a government hand out. It is about the fact that someone working hard, for long hours, can still, at the end of the day, not be able to support their family in a "comfortable" living. Can you say they should move out of the city where housing is cheaper? How will they get to their job in the city with gas prices as high as they are and no rapid rail transit to the valley? People are frustrated and it is reaching a boiling point. True, they are currently unorganized and unfocused with no clear goals, but there are enough of them world wide that should the right individual step in, they could electrify this disorganized mob into a Force for change.
-
Well put!
-
Sure but what's these poor saps' education level? What were they doing in high school / college?
-
Sure but what's these poor saps' education level? What were they doing in high school / college?
Who knows? Perhaps they had poor home life (alcoholic/drug abusing parents) and could not study at home, or perhaps they had an undiagnosed learning disability and could not keep up with their peers, or perhaps they WERE diagnosed with a learning disability but did not receive adequate learning assistance support due to government cuts in education spending, perhaps they could not afford college, shall I go on? Do not assume because someone is uneducated that they are lazy. There are a lot of reasons why someone may not be able to receive a post secondary education and find themselves in service industries. Many of them may even be working their way through college right now. They still deserve a respectable wage. If $9.50/hr was woefully inadequate in 1990, it certainly cannot be adequate in 2011. All I am saying is I understand why they are protesting. For Campbell to give himself a 40% wage increase in 2007 and then fight to keep the minimum wage down for fear that it would drive away businesses and bankrupt the province, is hypocritical. The greed of the 1% is at an all time high. It is happening all over the world and the 99% will not sit idle for ever. There has got to be a better way, a more sustainable way. The current system is not it.
-
Good post here Sandman. Not sure why people choose to make assumptions about people's backgrounds. The cracks in our system are growing wider and many people are falling though.
I am still against these occupy protests in Canada. Looks like a lot of doobie smoking and drum beating. Yes we have problems but there are jobs out there if people are willing to do them. We also have a much more stable banking system. The people making minimum wage are too busy working two jobs to crap on the lawn of the art gallery.
Who knows? Perhaps they had poor home life (alcoholic/drug abusing parents) and could not study at home, or perhaps they had an undiagnosed learning disability and could not keep up with their peers, or perhaps they WERE diagnosed with a learning disability but did not receive adequate learning assistance support due to government cuts in education spending, perhaps they could not afford college, shall I go on? Do not assume because someone is uneducated that they are lazy. There are a lot of reasons why someone may not be able to receive a post secondary education and find themselves in service industries. Many of them may even be working their way through college right now. They still deserve a respectable wage. If $9.50/hr was woefully inadequate in 1990, it certainly cannot be adequate in 2011. All I am saying is I understand why they are protesting. For Campbell to give himself a 40% wage increase in 2007 and then fight to keep the minimum wage down for fear that it would drive away businesses and bankrupt the province, is hypocritical. The greed of the 1% is at an all time high. It is happening all over the world and the 99% will not sit idle for ever. There has got to be a better way, a more sustainable way. The current system is not it.
-
Sure you can make assumptions that those people are disadvantaged but still does that qualify them to have same pay as those that worked hard?
-
An artical from the Kitimat times well written by a Mayoral candidate?
http://www.kitimatdaily.ca/show5117a0x300y1z/OCCUPY_KITIMAT
Worth a read ;)
-
Sandman, there are dozens of fine towns around this province with entry level jobs available and very inexpensive rents. Living in and around a major growing metropolis is not for everyone anymore.
People don't HAVE to live and work in the city. Sure, its a shame that house prices ( I blame immigration for this) and rental rates in Vancouver and the Valley are very high and that has pushed people out of the city, but this has happened in pretty much every major metropolitan city in the world. As a city grows, and in Vancouver's case be regarded as a great place to live, it brings in people with money and pushes out those from more modest means. But like we ALL know, this entire province is awesome, leave the city and the valley and push out further.
I lived in Lillooet for a year making $28,000 right out of University 7 years ago. Just two hours from Vancouver over the Duffy. Rent was under $400 and I lived a good life. I drove to Loops every couple of weeks to load up on Staples and had the Fraser River and many tributaries and small lakes all around me. I had peach, pear and apple trees in my back yard, local farmers market on the weekend. Very dry climate, terrific weather all around. Could have bought a decent house for $90,000-$125,000. But I CHOSE to move back to Vancouver and have a huge mortgage.
-
--min wage is announced by government but not set by them..
--There is nothing stopping companies from paying more!
--I owned a retail business and most competitors paid minimum wage I paid more... got the best people... and made more money.
--I don't care that people in the media dubbed Occupy movement have as many differing opinion's as the arm chair biologist do for a Thompson Steelhead recovery plan.
--Most will agree that Thompson steelhead are in trouble and one of the first steps to recovery is letting people know and identify the problem...
--Eventually some themes will emerge with accompanying solutions... we may not all agree on the path but at least they are doing something.
-
I remember working for $9.50 an hour and found it VERY difficult to make ends meet, paying rent, eating more than Mac n Cheese, buying gas etc. That was in the 90s. I cannot imagine what life is like for people working for minimum wage today, or worse as those poor saps at IHop who have to work for less (since they serve alcohol in IHop these servers will still only make only $8.75). This minimum wage is set by the politicians that only a few years ago voted themselves huge wage increases of between 20 - 40%. It is not hard to see why the protestors are occupying. The disparities are out of whack. It is not a matter of being lazy and wanting a government hand out. It is about the fact that someone working hard, for long hours, can still, at the end of the day, not be able to support their family in a "comfortable" living. Can you say they should move out of the city where housing is cheaper? How will they get to their job in the city with gas prices as high as they are and no rapid rail transit to the valley? People are frustrated and it is reaching a boiling point. True, they are currently unorganized and unfocused with no clear goals, but there are enough of them world wide that should the right individual step in, they could electrify this disorganized mob into a Force for change.
Good post here sandman. The thing that is being protested is the growing gap between rich and poor. Yes some were able to make it with a low wage but 9 dollars goes a much shorter distance these days. Damien I believe you are taking a bit of a narrow-minded stance here. I am far from a bleeding heart but the fact is it costs more to live and wages aren't rising. And no there really aren't tons of jobs in rural areas that is why there is so many people in the city, because that is where the entry level jobs are. To say people are here because they want to live and work in the city is not a fact.
-
Sure you can make assumptions that those people are disadvantaged but still does that qualify them to have same pay as those that worked hard?
Why do you assume that people that are paid less dont work as hard?. In my opinion it is often ( not always) the reverse people slave away doing undesirable work for low wage and some are exorbitantly compensated for doing very little comparatively.
-
Sure you can make assumptions that those people are disadvantaged but still does that qualify them to have same pay as those that worked hard?
On the contrary, I am not making "assumptions," as I prefaced each with "perhaps" indicating that there are a lot of reasons why someone may be "under educated" and working as unskilled labour. The "assumption" was that if one does not have a diploma or post secondary degree that qualifies them for a more lucrative salary, then they must have been slacking off in high school or college, and thus deserve a salary that keeps them below the poverty line. Any one of those possible scenarios I mentioned would have been a case of someone probably working twice as hard as I did in high school, but still not able to graduate or go on to college. Does someone with no skills deserve what I used to make as skilled labour, or what I make now as a professional? No, it does not, but they still deserve a respectable wage that allows them to live in dignity.