Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum
Fishing in British Columbia => General Discussion => Topic started by: Nutterbug on May 24, 2010, 11:22:03 AM
-
What are the pros and cons to each of these options?
-
float tube
PRo
cheaper
lighter
easy to pack
takes up less room
stable in heavy wind.( you body hanging in the water makes it less likely to blow around)
Cons
Can't anchor
feet in water all time can get cold.
limited range.
Pontoon
Pros
Oars
anchor system
can go down rivers, and whitewater.
Easy to mount rod holders,
Can carry gear.
Can mount electric motor
You sit higher in the water and better for casting.
Con
Heavy and take up a lot of space.
blow around in the wind more
These are my suggestions I have both.
-
Thanks.
Is the cheaper advantage to the float tube negated by the fact that you need good waders and flippers?
-
Have you looked into a pram?
-
Have you looked into a pram?
Has to be cheap and portable, ie. something inflatable.
-
You will need waders and fins with the pontoon as well so no that cost does not offset
-
you do NOT need flippers with a pontoon, i dont use any. I either row or use my motor to get around. I moved up from a float tube to the pontoon and now looking to get a flat bottom jon boat but will keep the pontoon of course.
someone said you cant anchor in a float tube ::) this is not true, i used to anchor all the time in my float tube so i could chironie fish effectively. I would recommend using something that wont grab much weeds off the bottom though and that doesnt weigh more then about 8lbs. I used to use a 7-8lb custom made anchor.
the biggest con i have found with a pontoon is that you are more prone to being moved around by the wind. I solved this by adding another anchor in the front. I have fished in some pretty forceful winds and not budged.
If you go the pontoon route make sure you shop around before buying one, i say this because some dont come with everything you may want on it. I have an Outcast Fishcat 9-IR which comes with a motor mount already on it. you can get cheaper ones (Creek Company for example) that dont have motor mounts and the outer potoon material is not nearly as strong. Look around for one used to save money, i see them on Craigslist or classifieds on fishing sites all the time.
-
You will need waders and fins with the pontoon as well so no that cost does not offset
I never used waders with my pontoon boat. Just rubber boots or sandles.
-
Pontton all the way. It;s way more comfortable and if you get lazy you can troll with an electric motor.
-
I bought a pontoon this year and love it
but as mentioned bulky to store
if you can not store as is you need time to break it down each time
it takes a while to set up once at the lake\river but well worth it forthe comfort
quicker to infalte than the tube and quicker to deflate, the extra time comes with putting the frame together
i still have my utube for smaller lakes and for ease if i only have a couple of hours to fish
As Hook says with the anchor you need two for the pontoon or you will swing back and forth
dont go cheap unless you get a good deal (craigslist-ebay etc) :)
one big pro for me i can get across the lake way quicker in the pontoon
-
--have you looked into something like the Dave Scadden H3.. on sale now on his US web site not sure what the price at Canadian stores is.
--hybrid light weight frameless pontoons.
--If I had limited space or was interested in pack in lakes I'd be looking at the Scadden models or outcast pro V styles.
--Some have foam floors others have blow up bladder style floors.
--once your bum is out of the water in float tubes like the pro V.. a lot faster to travel some distance than regular float tube where more of your body is in the water.
--On float tube I use the "float n tote" rod holder with built in anchor clamp system... use a small round downrigger ball or small wedge weight.
--on pontoon I use oars to get where I'm going but like the fins as both hands free to fish
--I haven't found a craft that will do everything...so think about where and how you are going to do the most fishing and go for the most suitable.
--It doesn't get any better when you have multiple craft... still have to make some compromise no matter where you go. Often best deal is used where owner has modified and added things that would cost a bundle if you had to get them new.
--PS... I've never sold a boat just keep adding to the fleet.
-
Cheap and portable = used float tube. I say used because there are lots around, they are dead simple to repair if they have leaks, and are cheap like borsht.
Pontoon, if you want half decent quality anyways, will move you out of the "cheap" category...unless you buy used, in which case you'll still be spending more than a new float tube.
Pontoons are relatively portable but have nothing on float tubes.
-
Are pontoons portable enough to fit into the trunk of a car with all your fishing gear?
-
Are pontoons portable enough to fit into the trunk of a car with all your fishing gear?
what kind of car and what kind of pontoon are you considering?
If it's something like a honda civic, probably not. The pontoons will collapse down but the frame might be a tight squeeze depending on how it's made. The scadden outlaw series can collapse down incredibly small but is also $$$...and good luck finding a used one.
I fit two pontoons, taken apart, in the back of my xterra and one pontoon (intact) on the roof. Still had roof for myself and 2 passengers (and all our gear) in the xterra.
All depends on your vehicle though, and if you're going alone or with others. Folding down rear seats would go a long ways if you're on your own.
-
In regards to the two posts above, I had a "cheap" candian tire classic pontoon boat that would fit in to my large hiking backpack and hiked into lakes.... In a back pack!!!!
I'd be a little surprised/chocked a pontoon boat would not fit into a car... But maybe the higher end ones don't break down???
-
Pontoon boats can fit in almost any car except for a smart car. This past long weekend I took a trip up to Kamloops for some trout fishing. In my VW Passat sedan we fit an outcast 9 ft. pontoon (with standing platform), and an 8 ft. pontoon boat, 4 fly rods, tents, sleeping bags, pump, 5 days worth of food, close to 100 beers, nets, 2 pairs of waders and boots, oars, gear, etc. Oh yeah and 2 regular sized people were able to comfortably fit in it as well. We could have fit even more stuff if needed and I was still able to fully see out of my back window. All this without even using the roof racks!
If I were you I would certainly go with a pontoon boat. One pro I did not see mentioned is how far one can go on a lake with a pontoon versus a float tube. I would love to see how long it takes for someone to get from the boat launch at Roche Lake to the good fishing holes (not including monster bay) with a float tube! Couple that with a windy day (which is normal for Roche) and you have almost no chance!
One pro for the float tube is that you can travel with it on planes to other fishing destinations throughout the world as it can fit in your suitcase easily with room to spare.
-
Pontoon boats can fit in almost any car except for a smart car. This past long weekend I took a trip up to Kamloops for some trout fishing. In my VW Passat sedan we fit an outcast 9 ft. pontoon (with standing platform), and an 8 ft. pontoon boat, 4 fly rods, tents, sleeping bags, pump, 5 days worth of food, close to 100 beers, nets, 2 pairs of waders and boots, oars, gear, etc. Oh yeah and 2 regular sized people were able to comfortably fit in it as well. We could have fit even more stuff if needed and I was still able to fully see out of my back window. All this without even using the roof racks!
If I were you I would certainly go with a pontoon boat. One pro I did not see mentioned is how far one can go on a lake with a pontoon versus a float tube. I would love to see how long it takes for someone to get from the boat launch at Roche Lake to the good fishing holes (not including monster bay) with a float tube! Couple that with a windy day (which is normal for Roche) and you have almost no chance!
One pro for the float tube is that you can travel with it on planes to other fishing destinations throughout the world as it can fit in your suitcase easily with room to spare.
100 beers ;D
Were you 2 sober enough to fish? LOL ;D ;D ;D
-
100 beers ;D
Were you 2 sober enough to fish? LOL ;D ;D ;D
Lol. Barely. We were glad to have all that beer once the snow and hail started though!
-
In regards to the two posts above, I had a "cheap" candian tire classic pontoon boat that would fit in to my large hiking backpack and hiked into lakes.... In a back pack!!!!
I'd be a little surprised/chocked a pontoon boat would not fit into a car... But maybe the higher end ones don't break down???
--There is such a variety.. not just cost.. you can get specialty boats two person pontoon, lake, river rated for hells gate or pontoon intended for backpacking
--without knowing what a person expects to do with the boat we can only give general advise.
--usually the more specialized you get the boat.. for example back packing, light weight light or no frame the less usefull it may be as an all around boat.
Some of the new high end boats have no frame and are still river rated. some frames are bolted together rather than using quick release pins.