Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum
Fishing in British Columbia => General Discussion => Topic started by: hookme on September 25, 2009, 03:52:08 AM
-
A right handed baitcast reel is cast with the right hand and is switched to the left hand to retrieve with the right hand..... WHY ? Just want to know some opinion... ;D ???
-
A right handed baitcast reel is cast with the right hand and is switched to the left hand to retrieve with the right hand..... WHY ? Just want to know some opinion... ;D ???
Good question!!
Perhaps it was developed by a left handed caster who preferred to wind in with their right hand?
That's why I always buy a baitcaster that I can cast right handed and wind in with my left. These are generally marked with a 1 or lh at the end of the model number IE. ABU 6501 or Curado 301 etc.
Of course some people can cast and wind with either hand. ::)
Hope this helps?
-
Most of my fishing years I have been using left handers only for a logical reason(no hands flipping). Than, about 10 years ago I developed painful and non healing "fisherman's shoulder". I had no choice but to acquire new right handed set of Calcuttas. and relearn left cast and right hand winding. After about 5 more years my arm healed, and now I always have with me two reels, left and right handed.It is very convenient in some situations.
-
The fact is that most people in this world are right handed, and from polls I've seen on other fishing sites in the past, a large portion of the world reels right handed too. It has a lot to do with our right hand being the most refined when it comes to motor skills, which allows us to reel faster right handed than we would with out left hand.
I'm one of those who casts with his right hand, switches to his left hand, and then reels with his right hand. Would it be EASIER if I was efficient at casting with my right hand, and then reeling with my left hand? Yes. But it's not easier for me, and I'm fairly certain no matter how much practice time I spent I'll always be a right-handed caster and reeler. I'm naturally right-handed.
Cheers,
Tex
-
A right handed baitcast reel is cast with the right hand and is switched to the left hand to retrieve with the right hand..... WHY ? Just want to know some opinion... ;D ???
Why don't you just cast with your left arm, keep the rod in your left hand and reel in with your right. If you are right handed you are more dexterous with a right handed reel - and you can make light adjustments with your left thumb to enhance drag. And anyone who can't hold a rod with their left arm is likely too weak to be on the river anyways.
-
I think it comes down to how you learned to fish.
Old school Canadian fishers cast with the rod on their right side and then reel with their right hand.
That was how my Dad fished and how he taught me.
Most of the people I see on TV (central Canadian & American shows) reel with their left hand.
-
Ya I reel with my left hand but cast with my right hand. To me this seems the only way, but can be reversed. I'm right handed to begin with so using my strong allow me perfect casts (some of the time :D). The reel arm (left) only reels and plays with line or most important controls drag.
Switching from 1 arm to another seems a little redundant and a pain in the my friend. I tried this once when borrowing another rod/reel. I found it easier to just lean how to do it with the other arm although my casts weren't the best it was fun learning something that I was taking for granted as being very, very easy.
It's like trying to write with the other hand, not so easy to do a "good job", and in fact a challenge.
-
I am right handed. I used right hand retreive reels.
When float fishing and chucking guts......
My rod usually doesn't leave my left arm/hand. When I cast, I swing side arm. Doesn't matter if I'm swinging from the left or right side. My rod always stays in my left hand.
When I'm tossing spoons on a spinning rod, I will usually cast overhand, and still use my left arm to cast and right to retreive.
-
This is an interesting thread, I cast with the right hand rod stays in right and reel it in with the left, I find it the most comfortable way to do it.
-
right handed, cast with the right, reel with the left. Left handed reel obviously ;)
-
Wow Thanks for the info Guys!! One reason why I like to know is when I using Baitcaster I used a left hand reel and cast my rod on my right Thinking this is the most fastest way and no need to switch although I'm right handed. But when I use my spinner I set my reel on the right kinda freaky ::) but I'm used to it. I was thinking to upgrade my baitcaster and use a right hand reel this time cause most of the time right hand is always available and I tried one of my friend's right hand it's not bad to switch take off the strain on your left hand...Goodluck this weekend! :)
-
With all these comments, can someone explain to me why they don't make big game reels left hand retrieve. i have search all the top manufacturer and talked to shimano but they don't seem to have a lefty version in a big game setup. why is that.
-
With all these comments, can someone explain to me why they don't make big game reels left hand retrieve. i have search all the top manufacturer and talked to shimano but they don't seem to have a lefty version in a big game setup. why is that.
It is not exactly true that there are no lefty versions of big game reels.
Penn has a few Senators and other models of over-the counter big game reels that come in LH configuration, and so do other manufacturers.
Some manufacturers of top-of-the-line stuff such as Alutecnos from Italy will make you a LH version of any of their models for a small extra charge. We are talking some state-of-the-art special order stuff that costs no less than 800-1200 bucks per reel, often more.
Serious big game fishers don't cheap out on their reels.
Plus, there is no casting involved in big game fishing, the control of the fish, once hooked, is all that matters.
-
With all these comments, can someone explain to me why they don't make big game reels left hand retrieve. i have search all the top manufacturer and talked to shimano but they don't seem to have a lefty version in a big game setup. why is that.
--hand made Everol makes left retrieve charges 12% good luck finding one in stock likely have to order it expect to wait several months if you get one.
--in todays market overseas manufacturers have such large min numbers that only the larger distributors could afford to get special left hand retrieve and likely would only do it for their most popular models. Obviously something like a fly reel with simple change most can be reversed but a multiplier reel more complex tooling for a conversion. In places like Australia bail spin reels or side cast reels are popular and can usually be reversed by the owner.
--I think just a cost issue for manufactuer and retailer. Would be difficult for retailer to sell same model at significantly higher price for us left crankers.
-
I've seen people who cast with the same hand they reel with.
I think they are simply confused.
They might be ambidextrous and have never realized the benefit of reeling with a different hand.
I know for myself I hit the golf ball going left, but it could have been the other way around.
It was just that the first time I took a golf club the person that taught me did it that way.
-
Tradition. I copied the following from Wikipedia - Fishing Reels:
Bait casting reel
Bait casting reels are reels in which line is stored on a bearing supported revolving spool. The bait casting reel is mounted above the rod, hence its other (though rarely used) name, the overhead reel. The bait casting reel dates from at least the mid-1600s, but came into wide use by amateur anglers during the 1870s. Early bait casting reels were often constructed with brass or iron gears, with casings and spools made of brass, German silver, or hard rubber. Early reels were often operated by inverting the reel and using back winding to retrieve line. For this reason, the reel crank handle was positioned on the right side of the reel.[6] As a result, the right-hand crank position for bait casting reels has become customary over the years, though models with left-hand retrieve are now gaining in popularity.
-
You can have the same debate about flyfishing reels. I cast right handed and have the reel knobs on the right hand side (ie retrieve right handed). When I bought my first fly rod, I asked the shop to set me up for left handed retrieve. The shopkeeper gave me a strange look and said it was easier to retrieve the other way. I used the left handed retrieve for a while and did find that while stripping and handling the line, the line would sometimes get caught up with the left side knobs. Then I watched "A River Runs Through It" again and noticed that Brad Pitt (or his double) cast right handed but had a right hand retrieve reel. So I switched my reel over to right hand retrieve. Now I am used to it.
I use a right hand retrieve on my baitcaster. I cast right and actually like switching to left for the drift or fight. I get less fatigued. I also find that it is easier to just use the left hand to hold the rod and the right hand to retrieve while fighting a fish.
On the other hand, I cast right but retrieve left with a spinning rod.
One reason I have shied away from buying a centerpin is because I have no idea which way to set up the reel.
-
thanks for the input, i will take a look at those reels. i'm a big fan of shimano and the torsa is super nice to hold and stuff. but i will look at the others that you guys have mentioned. thanks again.
-
The fact is that most people in this world are right handed, and from polls I've seen on other fishing sites in the past, a large portion of the world reels right handed too. It has a lot to do with our right hand being the most refined when it comes to motor skills, which allows us to reel faster right handed than we would with out left hand.
I'm one of those who casts with his right hand, switches to his left hand, and then reels with his right hand. Would it be EASIER if I was efficient at casting with my right hand, and then reeling with my left hand? Yes. But it's not easier for me, and I'm fairly certain no matter how much practice time I spent I'll always be a right-handed caster and reeler. I'm naturally right-handed.
Cheers,
Tex
Ditto when fishing gear, but I reel and strip left when fly fishing- probably because the rod is always mending line whenever there's a current or a breeze and that requires precise motor skills that my left hand just doesn't possess.
-
Abu Ambassadeur c6501 is an awesome reel, and very reasonably priced (especially if you look on EBAY) and it will last forever if you treat it right
-
If you grew up near the ocean and fished with Islander reels, the early Islanders were right hand only.
-
baitcasters(levelwind) - cast left handed, reel right handed = no hand switching
centre pin - cast left, reel right (fish a Silex so it is only right hand anyways) = no hand switching
spinning rod - cast rigth,reel left = no hand switching
fly rod - cast right handed,reel and strip lefty = no hand switching
spey rod - cast with both hands and reel is setup for right hand retrieve = not really much hand switching depending on river direction.
when i started fly fishing especially my reel was setup right hand reeling and i found that i lost fish trying to switch hands either missing strikes right after the fly hit the water or when the fish got slack while bringing it in :(
I find im on the ball alot more when i dont have to switch hands. even when drift fishing i have caught fish almost instantly when it hits the water and also the fact i can start controlling my drifts instantly because there is no hand switching.
just some food for thought ;)
-
--if you want to get comfortable with a switch you have to practice.
--go down to your local fishing shop and offer to spool reels for the day in stead of using a their machine.
--Kind of like practicing your cast, soon learn a comfortable technique and fun to hang out in the shop for a day or two.
--
-
One reason I have shied away from buying a centerpin is because I have no idea which way to set up the reel.
I cast a fly rod right and reel right but I have started using the center pin and cast left and reel right, give it a try it is very nice to use.