Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum

Fishing in British Columbia => General Discussion => Topic started by: clarki on October 17, 2014, 09:38:55 PM

Title: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: clarki on October 17, 2014, 09:38:55 PM
Me.

While fishing today, my retrieve brought in a length of braid...at least 60 pound. Thick stuff.

I was pulling it out of the water and saw a DNE float along it's length. Cool! Maybe I get get it in.

As I hand bombed the line in, a fish started tugging on the other end. Double cool! Maybe I can get a DNE float AND a fish. :)   

So I wrapped the line around my hand for extra purchase...and then I saw the chum...and then the line started to cut into my hand.

Brilliant move Shakepeare. You've got braid wrapped around your hand and you're playing a chum in the current. You didn't want that hand anyways, did you?

Fortunately the hook pulled free before the braid severed my hand. No fish...but I got the float!

On another note, what a spectacular day. Fall colours, low lying cloud clinging to the mountain sides, steady rain, mild temps, abundant birds (eagles, herons, dippers, horned grebes...I think I watched the dippers more than I watched my float) and more coho than I deserve.  Plus, I still have my hand and I'm +1 in the DNE department! :)       
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Shawn6o4 on October 17, 2014, 10:12:27 PM
Ouch! I've cut into my fingers a few times tying knots with braid doesn't feel too good can't imagine with a fish on the other end lol
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: 4TheKids on October 17, 2014, 10:29:24 PM
Nice post. Love honest stories where it is 'how the h3ll did things go so wrong". Thanks.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Flytech on October 18, 2014, 06:54:26 AM
My braid slices through my fingers so easy. Even trying to pull a minor nest cuts me. I'm glad you're ok!
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: RalphH on October 18, 2014, 08:29:53 AM

On another note, what a spectacular day. Fall colours, low lying cloud clinging to the mountain sides, steady rain, mild temps, abundant birds (eagles, herons, dippers, horned grebes...I think I watched the dippers more than I watched my float) and more coho than I deserve.  Plus, I still have my hand and I'm +1 in the DNE department! :)     
Some years it seems there are more dippers than other years. Back '02 I fished the upper river and had one dipper that was so conditioned to fishermen she would swim on the surface within a couple of feet of me, sculling along with her wings and looking up at me while going by. I could have sworn she winked!
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Stewie on October 18, 2014, 12:49:13 PM
That is a great story. Thanks for the entertainment.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: KarateKick on October 18, 2014, 01:48:59 PM
I guess that means I shouldn't put braid on the kids' reels? Are all braid lines sharp?
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: firstlight on October 18, 2014, 06:44:37 PM
Im thinking its time that braid line is banned in rivers.
That stuff is nasty.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: TheFishingLad on October 18, 2014, 06:54:08 PM
Im thinking its time that braid line is banned in rivers.
That stuff is nasty.

I think it's great stuff, certainly has it's purpose. I just feel it and the rod needs to be properly maintained to avoid breakage on the mainline. Most importantly use a swivel and proper leader so you only use 1-3ft of mono.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: clarkii on October 18, 2014, 06:58:37 PM
Can someone explain how a chum broke off on 60lb braid?

Only thing I'd think of is the line was abraded/deteriorated when it broke suddenly.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: CohoJake on October 18, 2014, 07:34:02 PM
Can someone explain how a chum broke off on 60lb braid?

Only thing I'd think of is the line was abraded/deteriorated when it broke suddenly.
Earlier this season I lost half of a ceramic ring from one of my guides.  I didn't notice until I broke my braid off 50 yards of braid when I was hung up on bottom.  I've had the same thing happen with my rod tip and mono. 
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: clarki on October 18, 2014, 07:57:53 PM
I could have sworn she winked!

I don't doubt it. Rumour is you are quite a handsome devil.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Speyhead on October 19, 2014, 02:31:41 AM
Im thinking its time that braid line is banned in rivers.
That stuff is nasty.

That and spiderwire type lines, saw a guy nearly lose a finger on the saltchuck, he tried a straight pull on his snagged line with the line wrapped around his hand.....this was from a boat in a good swell, the boat moved upwards and this thinner ultra strong line almost pulled him over the side.

It also sliced his pinkie and ring fingers to the bone :o
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Flytech on October 19, 2014, 07:25:42 AM
That and spiderwire type lines, saw a guy nearly lose a finger on the saltchuck, he tried a straight pull on his snagged line with the line wrapped around his hand.....this was from a boat in a good swell, the boat moved upwards and this thinner ultra strong line almost pulled him over the side.

It also sliced his pinkie and ring fingers to the bone :o


You can't fix stupid.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: typhoon on October 19, 2014, 07:48:41 AM
I have fished braid for years on my float rod and have never lost a foot of it.
You have to do something stupid to lose any significant amount of braid - get spooled by a fish, use mono backing and have it break at the knot, use really old braid.

If you want to clean up the river ban mono. There is way more of it lying around than braid and it is much easier to lose a lot of line.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: RalphH on October 19, 2014, 09:26:02 AM
Ban mono, ban braid, ban bouncing bettys, ban hooks bigger than2/0, ban roe, ban all bait - easy to get rid of all this stuff is to ban fishing.  ;D

As far loosing a hand or a finger - that could happen with any line. I'd say the biggest danger there would have been loosing a hand due to asphyxiation. My own near Darwin award experience was setting the hook on a salmon with loose fly line off the reel it slipped out of my finger and as the rod went up a loop of line went around my neck - I was within 20 seconds of a nomination but the fish stayed still and didn't run.

 Braids can cut by simply touching the line while a large fish is running out line. Coated braids like Powerpro or Tufline Xp are far less likely to do that kind of damage.

Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: bald_seagull on October 19, 2014, 10:12:35 AM
Ban mono, ban braid, ban bouncing bettys, ban hooks bigger than2/0, ban roe, ban all bait - easy to get rid of all this stuff is to ban fishing.  ;D



love the sarcasm

Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: GordJ on October 19, 2014, 05:10:00 PM
Ban mono, ban braid, ban bouncing bettys, ban hooks bigger than2/0, ban roe, ban all bait - easy to get rid of all this stuff is to ban fishing.  ;D

As far loosing a hand or a finger - that could happen with any line. I'd say the biggest danger there would have been loosing a hand due to asphyxiation. My own near Darwin award experience was setting the hook on a salmon with loose fly line off the reel it slipped out of my finger and as the rod went up a loop of line went around my neck - I was within 20 seconds of a nomination but the fish stayed still and didn't run.

 Braids can cut by simply touching the line while a large fish is running out line. Coated braids like Powerpro or Tufline Xp are far less likely to do that kind of damage.
Similar story today, hooked a chum and when I reeled in to get the fish on the reel I put a hitch on my finger. Had a b@&$h of a time getting slack and an extra hand to unhook finger and hold rod. Ban fly lines.
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Noahs Arc on October 20, 2014, 11:48:17 AM
That and spiderwire type lines, saw a guy nearly lose a finger on the saltchuck, he tried a straight pull on his snagged line with the line wrapped around his hand.....this was from a boat in a good swell, the boat moved upwards and this thinner ultra strong line almost pulled him over the side.

It also sliced his pinkie and ring fingers to the bone :o

So because some dummy cut himself doing something stupid, we should ban braid?
Title: Re: Idiot almost loses hand
Post by: Hohummm on October 20, 2014, 02:02:30 PM
Me.

While fishing today, my retrieve brought in a length of braid...at least 60 pound. Thick stuff.

I was pulling it out of the water and saw a DNE float along it's length. Cool! Maybe I get get it in.

As I hand bombed the line in, a fish started tugging on the other end. Double cool! Maybe I can get a DNE float AND a fish. :)   

So I wrapped the line around my hand for extra purchase...and then I saw the chum...and then the line started to cut into my hand.

Brilliant move Shakepeare. You've got braid wrapped around your hand and you're playing a chum in the current. You didn't want that hand anyways, did you?

Fortunately the hook pulled free before the braid severed my hand. No fish...but I got the float!

On another note, what a spectacular day. Fall colours, low lying cloud clinging to the mountain sides, steady rain, mild temps, abundant birds (eagles, herons, dippers, horned grebes...I think I watched the dippers more than I watched my float) and more coho than I deserve.  Plus, I still have my hand and I'm +1 in the DNE department! :)     

Had a similar (but less injurous) incident on the Stave on Saturday. Fishing colorado blades and the float slowed down in the current. Figured it had hung up on something so started to bring it in. Float started moving upstream as it came in, then I saw that the blade was hooked on a piece of mono. Not an uncommon thing in the Stave but still unusual in deeper water, got it in close enough to shore to grab the garbage line and started pulling it in to get it out of the way...A bit surprised when it started pulling back! Managed to bring in a somewhat coloured chum doe with a nice shiny crocodile in her dorsal fin along with about 100 ft of line. Set her on her way free of the incumberance and added the croc to the tackle box!
Title: Wii
Post by: Aurora on October 20, 2014, 07:09:36 PM
Should we all fish with Nintendo Wii?  I would rather risk a possible injury.