Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum
Fishing in British Columbia => Fly Fishing Cafe => Topic started by: BC Fishing on February 07, 2017, 12:57:43 PM
-
"We set up an experiment to see if smelly flies had an effect on Trout but we didn't expect what we saw!
Have a look for yourself."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C61xoE-jSE8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C61xoE-jSE8)
-
I found that to be far less exciting than I thought it would be.
I don't like the concept of scented flies.
-
Might as well post this in general discussion.
-
If you think your flies don't already have a scent - you're dreamin'
-
If you think your flies don't already have a scent - you're dreamin'
I don't think they don't, I recognize that flies get trace scent from the materials they are tied with. However I am not convinced these trace scents attract fish, take foam dry flies for example or flies such as tequila boobies, synthetic materials everywhere and they work really well. One of the best winter nymphs for our area uses only one natural material, and it is the tail.
Adding scent for the purpose of attracting fish however is outside those naturally in the materials and constitutes bait fishing.
-
who can tell me why anise oil or garlic attract fish? There is no anise nor garlic in the any water.
-
who can tell me why anise oil or garlic attract fish? There is no anise nor garlic in the any water.
They don't attract fish. They mask the bad human scents that repel fish.
-
They don't attract fish. They mask the bad human scents that repel fish.
that's the other thing on your flies clarkii - the stinky smell of fingers. We used to spit on lures & bait - it seemed to work.
Most feathers and fur actually have quite an appreciable amount of scent. Bucktail and deer hair can be almost rank - hardly describable as a trace.
-
--Maybe they should only allow use of fly's in areas where bait fishing is allowed then.
-
who can tell me why anise oil or garlic attract fish? There is no anise nor garlic in the any water.
Pretty sure these aren't made to mask human scent
https://www.amazon.com/PowerBait-Natural-Glitter-Trout-Bait/dp/B003VUT7LY
http://www.lakemichiganangler.com/store/Luhr_Jensen_Eggs.htm
that's the other thing on your flies clarkii - the stinky smell of fingers. We used to spit on lures & bait - it seemed to work.
Most feathers and fur actually have quite an appreciable amount of scent. Bucktail and deer hair can be almost rank - hardly describable as a trace.
If you have almost rank materials they were not preserved properly.
Please explain how the bacteria and enzymes in your mouth mirror the scent found in the oils of your hand. ::)
-
Trout salmon and most fish are able to detect scents & tastes far beyond what humans can, so if you think 'cause you can't detect such in tying materials well don't assume fish can't.
-
Pretty sure these aren't made to mask human scent
https://www.amazon.com/PowerBait-Natural-Glitter-Trout-Bait/dp/B003VUT7LY
http://www.lakemichiganangler.com/store/Luhr_Jensen_Eggs.htm
If you have almost rank materials they were not preserved properly.
Please explain how the bacteria and enzymes in your mouth mirror the scent found in the oils of your hand. ::)
Spit contains food. Cheese, bread, peanut butter, and coffee are great masking agents. A lot of old timers swore that tobacco smoke was also effective.
-
Spit contains food. Cheese, bread, peanut butter, and coffee are great masking agents. A lot of old timers swore that tobacco smoke was also effective.
So scent is a joke or something. What the scent is going to mask then? How could fish hate human scent more than cheese, peanut butter and tobacco? And what is human scent anyway.
-
So scent is a joke or something. What the scent is going to mask then? How could fish hate human scent more than cheese, peanut butter and tobacco? And what is human scent anyway.
That is an odd statement. Salmon and steelhead use trace scents to return to the water of their birth. Even small amounts of bad stuff can turn them away from your offering.
"Human" scent includes petroleum products, perfumes and other human made smells that fish don't like.
-
Trout salmon and most fish are able to detect scents & tastes far beyond what humans can, so if you think 'cause you can't detect such in tying materials well don't assume fish can't.
Im still waiting for you to explain how oily hands are the same as spit.
-
I think you have the relationship bass akwards ::)