Fishing with Rod Discussion Forum

Fishing in British Columbia => General Discussion => Topic started by: 180gall on May 04, 2011, 09:49:07 AM

Title: Braid or no braid
Post by: 180gall on May 04, 2011, 09:49:07 AM
 So I have never used braided line befor but can see it's benefits.
However does braided line break down slower or create more of
a snag potential than mono.
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: TheChumWhisperer on May 04, 2011, 02:27:24 PM
You dont need braid unless you are fishing the Fraser.  In clear, fresh water rivers there is never a need to use braid.  15-20lb mainline will handle anything you catch. 
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: EZ_Rolling on May 04, 2011, 02:39:41 PM
I run braid on all my reels , seems like more of a personal preference more than anything.

It works for me ...your results may vary

Personally I do not understand the statement "only on the Fraser"
as there are as many pros as cons with either choice.

EZ
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: alwaysfishn on May 04, 2011, 02:40:52 PM
Works very well in the ocean as well.
.....Particularly if you're trying to catch your share of the 12% Halibut allocation.  :D

I would think it would break down much slower than mono and if casting with it, be careful not to get a birds nest as it is more difficult to untangle. Initially it must be wound very tightly on your reel or you will have problems. Because of its small diameter relative to mono line you can load much more line on a reel.
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: steelie-slayer on May 04, 2011, 03:19:11 PM
personaly i prefer mono...
maxima ug 12 lb for the levelwind
maxima 12 lb chamelion on the pin...
had braided was nice as it held more line but i got a snag with it and the main line snapped half way between snag and rod, and this was only the first time using it.
braid also is horrible for winter as i it gets wet it freezes.
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Robert_G on May 04, 2011, 04:30:25 PM
When I first tried braided for the Fraser for bottom bouncing, there was no question that it is far superior to mono for that type of fishing.
I tried in one time in the Vedder and never again.
Braided line is for flossing Sockeye in the Fraser and it's not too bad on a Bar Rig. All other stream fishing should be mono.
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: brownmancheng on May 04, 2011, 04:57:01 PM
When I first tried braided for the Fraser for bottom bouncing, there was no question that it is far superior to mono for that type of fishing.
I tried in one time in the Vedder and never again.
Braided line is for flossing Sockeye in the Fraser and it's not too bad on a Bar Rig. All other stream fishing should be mono.
What made it far superior for bottom bouncing and flossing??
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: penn on May 04, 2011, 05:17:46 PM
What made it far superior for bottom bouncing and flossing??
Much stronger for pulling snagged weights off the bottom . Way less stretch for very long casts makes setting the hook more effective . Much stronger when playing out a very strong spring with unlimited room to run . Better feel due to it being much more rigid .
Having said that , it really sucks for the Chilliwack , highly visible and guys who use it get snagged on the bottom and snap off leave much worse snags for everyone else to get caught on .
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Rickjames_22 on May 04, 2011, 06:01:52 PM
yeah, as has been said, i find braid is a great line for the fraser river, durability and all that jazz... what i liked the most was the lack of memory, just a dream to work with...

but on the Vedder i don't like it, if not for the reasons mentioned, i just get a little paranoid that fish can see it, looks like steel cable in the water...
i use 12-15 maxima mono for my levelwind on the chedder
also i run 12lb chameleon on my islander pin...
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Bently on May 04, 2011, 06:34:24 PM
I think it is great for Sturgeon and possibly Halibut fishing, but I'll stick with the mono for all other BC game fish.  ;)

Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: coho13 on May 04, 2011, 06:47:37 PM
braid for bar fishing/bottom bounce mono for anything else
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: 1son on May 04, 2011, 09:21:01 PM
Braid is good for big game and for spinning reels rather than levelwind in my own experience birds nest a lot but really depends on what kind of fishing your doing. All my fishing is done with mono except sturgeon and sometimes salmon it has it's benefits but there's a flip side to that coin as does everything else really just a personal preference some like it some don't up to you good luck
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: EZ_Rolling on May 05, 2011, 07:29:43 AM
all the cons I see here are not the fault of the line but more the operator.

if your snagging up your fishing too deep, if your getting too many birdsnests ....learn how to cast.

this season I fished with one float for the full steelhead season, the line visibility did not seem to be a problem either as I had several nice fish to the beach and was my best steel year on the Vedder by far.
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: 180gall on May 05, 2011, 07:38:29 AM
Thanks everyone for your opinions
I'm thinking I'll give braid a try where it will benefit me the most
(my bar set up)   see how I like it and go from there.  ;D
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: wonder on May 05, 2011, 03:29:02 PM
personally i hate braid, used it all last yr, had more success and less frustration with mono this season. just my 2cents
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Sandhead on May 06, 2011, 12:46:17 PM
I use 120lb braided  on my sturgeon setups
mono on my ocean  downrigger rods
everything else gets the flyrod
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Silex-user on May 06, 2011, 11:22:43 PM
I use braid line for Bar fishing in the Fraser river and used it in ocean for jigging bottom fishes. Works great.



Silex-user
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: younggun on May 07, 2011, 02:39:03 AM
Fraser fishing, sturgeon, halibut, and spoon fishing (in certain places)
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Ned on May 09, 2011, 07:06:35 PM
One thing I noticed is that braided line frays a lot when using float stoppers with wire catches .. and almost impossible to stop line from bunching up at these stoppers.
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: joska on May 09, 2011, 07:24:20 PM
i got it on my bar rods, sturgeon set ups.  and on the flipping stick but I will stick with the mono/fluorocarbon for all other fishing applications
Title: Re: Braid or no braid
Post by: Iyekim76 on May 16, 2011, 02:12:37 AM
Been using braid since the '09 pink run and love it. Im running Power Pro 65ib. for ocean, Fraser, Stave including the Vedder/ and have had success including landing 2 steelies this year! Here are the pros and cons:

Pro:
-smaller diameter
-strength and durability
-highly visible(us)
-easier to fix birds nest than mono(IMO)
-no memory
-no stretch

Cons:
-snags(due to strength, it can be a
Hindrance especially if you have to cut line)
-slowly wrecks the guides
-slowly wrecks the reel
-highly visible(fish)
-pricey

New technology should have these braided lines improve drastically visibility issues. If you do end up lining with braid, use 30ibs and up and have the tackle shop line it for you. Might be cheaper than purchasing 300yard spools. I've been using Power pro main and 12-20ibs fluorocarbon leader depending on the situation and will stick with it with most applications for recreational game fishing with gear...

Hope it somewhat helps. Fish on & tight lines!

Mike